Live From Supreme Court Source Live Law
Keep Visiting we are updating Here
4G to be started on trial basis in one each district in Kashmir and Jammu province respectively after August 15. Area not adjoining border,LOC/Area with low intensity of violence, spillover effect on neighbouring area.
Attorney General KK Venugopal: The special committee held a meeting on August 10 and after considering the situation prevalent and security of nation, it was of the view that threat perception on security continues to be high
Committee was of the considered view that the situation in Jammu & Kashmir is still not conducive to restore internet Services of 4G in Jammu & Kashmir.
AG: A carefully calibrated view was taken and on a trial basis, the committee has stated that High speed internet could be restored in certain area with strict monitoring.Area should have low threshold of terrorist activities.
AG: The Internet restoration will be restored in certain areas for a trial basis for a period of two months.
AG: The Committee will overlook this restoration in certain areas of Jammu & Kashmir over a period of 7 days.
This shall come into force after August 15,2020.
AG: All orders have been put up on the website.
Plus — The review committee deliberations cannot be put out there
Justice Ramana: Theres no need to put out orders of special committee out there. This committee was formulated by usz
Ahmadi: I understand, notification of the same not required as formed by My lords.
However, the Review Committee was required to conduct review every week.
Justice Reddy: No no, this was a one-time measure.
Justice Reddy now telling Mr. Ahmadi to look at the order passed on May 11.
Justice Reddy now reading out its own order of May 11.
Says the special committee is to assist the regular committee.
We have not overruled Anuradha Bhasin.
Ahmadi: Thats not how I have understood it. However, the order should be in public domain.
AG: Special Committee - on a trial basis - to assist the Govt. It is purely advisory.
The regular committee’s orders - whenever a decision is taken, it is put out there in public domain.
Ahmadi: The order in review is not in public domain.
Ahmadi: Today, if i have to challenge the order, how will I do so. Let them place it on record. Let them place one.
AG: I don’t know what hes talking about. If hes talking about the Statutory orders, they are in public domain.
AG: The statutory orders are in public domain.
Ahmadi: None of the orders on review are posted. Is AG is making a wrong statement in court? I don’t know what to say...
Ahmadi: The orders the AG is referring to (of July 8) are regular orders — they are not orders in review. The review order is not on the Website.
It is not in public domain.
SG: The decision once reviewed becomes a regular decision. Ahmadi: All orders are valid for only two weeks which are required to be reviewed.
Justice Ramana: You are concerned about the fact that Anuradha Bhasin has not been complied with and review ordera not in public domain. Ahmadi: Yes, second argument is the review needs to be done every 5 days.. Justice Ramana : Contempt is closed. How many days you need to reply to the IA? A week. Grants two weeks to file reply. Ahmadi : Today is a good day. A step forward has been taken. Justice Ramana : Contempt is closed. How many days you need to reply to the IA? A week. Grants two weeks to file reply. Ahmadi : Today is a good day. A step forward has been taken
ORDER:
The aspect of contempt has been closed with no objection by Petitioner in light of the staggered restoration of 4G in certain areas
Respondents to file a reply on (2 weeks)-
1) orders of review committee in public domain;
2) review of internet restoration every 5 days.
. More To Come Stay Here
AG: All orders have been put up on the website.
Plus — The review committee deliberations cannot be put out there
Justice Ramana: Theres no need to put out orders of special committee out there. This committee was formulated by usz
Ahmadi: I understand, notification of the same not required as formed by My lords.
However, the Review Committee was required to conduct review every week.
Justice Reddy: No no, this was a one-time measure.
Justice Reddy now telling Mr. Ahmadi to look at the order passed on May 11.
Justice Reddy now reading out its own order of May 11.
Says the special committee is to assist the regular committee.
We have not overruled Anuradha Bhasin.
Ahmadi: Thats not how I have understood it. However, the order should be in public domain.
AG: Special Committee - on a trial basis - to assist the Govt. It is purely advisory.
The regular committee’s orders - whenever a decision is taken, it is put out there in public domain.
Ahmadi: The order in review is not in public domain.
Ahmadi: Today, if i have to challenge the order, how will I do so. Let them place it on record. Let them place one.
AG: I don’t know what hes talking about. If hes talking about the Statutory orders, they are in public domain.
AG: The statutory orders are in public domain.
Ahmadi: None of the orders on review are posted. Is AG is making a wrong statement in court? I don’t know what to say...
Ahmadi: The orders the AG is referring to (of July 8) are regular orders — they are not orders in review. The review order is not on the Website.
It is not in public domain.
SG: The decision once reviewed becomes a regular decision. Ahmadi: All orders are valid for only two weeks which are required to be reviewed.
Justice Ramana: You are concerned about the fact that Anuradha Bhasin has not been complied with and review ordera not in public domain. Ahmadi: Yes, second argument is the review needs to be done every 5 days.. Justice Ramana : Contempt is closed. How many days you need to reply to the IA? A week. Grants two weeks to file reply. Ahmadi : Today is a good day. A step forward has been taken. Justice Ramana : Contempt is closed. How many days you need to reply to the IA? A week. Grants two weeks to file reply. Ahmadi : Today is a good day. A step forward has been taken
ORDER:
The aspect of contempt has been closed with no objection by Petitioner in light of the staggered restoration of 4G in certain areas
Respondents to file a reply on (2 weeks)-
1) orders of review committee in public domain;
2) review of internet restoration every 5 days.
. More To Come Stay Here
